Local Crabs
Fresh Shrimp
Fish of the Day

Crabs sold by the
Dozen/1/2 Bushel/Bushel

• Dozen(s) Bushel(s)

• Med Large

• Large - Jumbo

• Colossal

Shrimp sold by
the Half & Full Pound

• Jumbo

• Large

• Medium

Eat In or Take Out


Restaurant & Take-Out @ 300 Coastal, Hwy. Finwick Island

View Menu and Call in Your Order (Online Store Coming Soon)

Fish sold by the Pound

• Salmon
• Flounder

• Rockfish

• Seasonal Catches

Located on the Chincoteague Bay and Fenwick Island, our blue crabs and other fresh seafood are caught daily, selected by hand before being served to our satisfied customers. Enjoy fresh Maryland, Delaware and Virginia Seafood anywhere. Buy our seafood online with confidence.


Restaurant & Take-Out @ 300 Coastal, Hwy. Finwick Island

Customer Reviews “We were looking for a casual place to eat seafood and boy did we hit the jackpot.” Cyndi Potenza-Clark "WOW!! just got the fish tacos. opened the box and WOW look on my face should have been captured. not only is it appealing to look at it tastes AMAZING!!! Thank you Chris!! must try this place. I will come for more food before i leave for Florida the end of September. btw also must add the banana bread is very good." Cara Moore "Went there for the first time last night. Loved the casual, friendly atmosphere and really enjoyed chatting with Chris. Crabs were excellent! We will be back for sure!" Ruthie Folio Robinson "We had a wonderful dinner at Rusty Jimmies! Food was delish (crabs were spectacular) and service by Chris was excellent. We loved this casual, low key atmosphere!!" Kimberly Allen "I never experienced eating a blue crab before tonight....At Rusty Jimmies they came to our table and taught me all about the blue crab and the best way to eat one...It was so delicious and fun to eat. I also had for the first time a soft shell crab with crab meat on top..It was amazing and very fresh they catch their own everyday and you sure can tell by the quality of their fresh seafood..... A definite place to go if your looking for the best fresh seafood around!!!" Terri Landi Mahadeen

Call to Order!


Rusty Jimmie's Crab & Seafood Restaurant

Fresh Crabs & Seafood

Dine-In or Take Out

Menu - Take-Out or Dine In - "BYOB"

Now Open Summer Hours!

Stop in for Lunch & Dinner Deals!